ChatGPT Vs. Gemini Vs. Claude: What Are The Variations?

Chatbots have modified many professionals’ workflows and processes. Accountants, attorneys, website positioning consultants, writers, businesses, builders, and even academics are nonetheless discussing the adjustments happening of their discipline due to instruments like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude.

If you wish to seek for info, need assistance fixing bugs in your CSS, wish to create one thing so simple as a robots.txt file, or want purchasing suggestions, chatbots might be able to assist.

They’re additionally fantastic for matter ideation, permitting you to draft extra fascinating emails, newsletters, weblog posts, and extra.

However which chatbot must you use and study to grasp? Which platform supplies correct, concise info?

Issues have modified lots since 2022, 2023, and even for the reason that begin of 2025.

Let’s discover out the place every platform stands at the moment.

What Is The Distinction Between ChatGPT, Gemini, And Claude?

ChatGPT Vs. Gemini Vs. Claude: Immediate Testing And Examples

Since technical website positioning is an space I’m enthusiastic about, I wished to see what the chatbots need to say once I put the next immediate in every:

What Are The High 3 Technical website positioning Elements I Can Use To Optimize My Web site?

ChatGPT’s Response

ChatGPT supplies a coherent, well-structured response to this question. The response does contact on three necessary areas of optimization:

• Web site velocity.
• Crawlability and indexability.
• Construction and schema markup.

When prompted to supply extra info on website velocity, we obtain a variety of nice info that you need to use to start optimizing your website.

However that is simply the beginning of the suggestions supplied. ChatGPT additionally really useful:

• Find out how to check and monitor efficiency, together with 4 instruments to make use of.
• Find out how to optimize velocity, with suggestions for optimizing photos, utilizing a content material supply community, caching, and minifying code.
• Superior optimization for builders, corresponding to preloading and fetching sources.

ChatGPT impressed me with an intensive response on website velocity optimization. You possibly can even create a guidelines to obtain step-by-step optimization directions.

Gemini’s Response

Gemini’s responses are quicker than ChatGPT and equally as informative.

The data is stable, and I respect that Google makes use of extra formatting, tables, and daring elements within the responses to make them simpler to learn.

An fascinating, and perhaps self-serving tidbit, is that Gemini offered a subsequent step that mentioned: Do you may have Google Search Console arrange in your website? That’s the perfect instrument to audit all three of those technical elements, particularly Core Internet Vitals and Indexing points.

To try to preserve issues comparable, I requested Gemini, “Are you able to present extra info on Web site Velocity & Consumer Expertise (Core Internet Vitals)?”

Gemini got here again with an intensive response, overlaying:

• Understanding Core Internet Vitals (CWV): A full rationalization of LCP, INP, and CLS was offered, together with what it measures, goal scores, and what occurs when it’s poor.
• Why CWV is Important for website positioning: 4 examples got, together with web page expertise, mobile-first significance, decrease bounce fee, and conversion affect.

Optimization suggestions have been additionally offered, which I’ll present you under:

Gemini supplies good responses for all of their suggestions, however you’ll have to dig deeper into them in case you don’t know the way a few of these work. For instance, minimizing main-thread work is way extra complicated for the common individual and would require considerably extra steerage.

However you’ll be able to immediate it to learn to reduce main-thread work or optimize your JavaScript correctly.

I really feel like ChatGPT beat out Gemini with this superior response, extra so as a result of it was in-depth. Gemini feels such as you’ll have to preserve prompting it for a number of the suggestions as a result of they’re extra superior.

Claude has been actually sturdy as of late, particularly with coding, however let’s see what it might probably do with technical website positioning.

Claude’s Response

Claude’s solutions are all fairly stable, however I discovered them extra informative than actionable, which is one thing I appreciated prior to now. Whereas some suggestions are supplied for every part, the intention appears to be to coach first and motion second.

Let’s probe it a bit extra on website velocity with this query: “Are you able to present extra info on Web page Velocity & Core Internet Vitals?”

Claude’s response is in depth, and that is simply a part of it.

What I didn’t present you to chop again on the screenshots is that Claude really useful instruments (prefer it has carried out prior to now) and fast wins to get essentially the most out of optimization, corresponding to compression and next-gen picture codecs.

Winner: Claude and ChatGPT win out, due to their in depth solutions and point out of particular instruments and actionable steps. Google shied away from recommending instruments (apart from its personal), however they did present hyperlinks to search out out extra information.

I do wish to point out Claude’s reply can be extra invaluable if they really linked to instruments, however they didn’t.

Superior Immediate: I Have a Small Canine. Can You Suggest 5 Canine Beds for Them?

I wished to check out ChatGPT’s “purchase it in ChatGPT” characteristic, so this immediate will closely favor the platform.

However it’s price exploring a bit and seeing what occurs sooner or later as Gemini and Claude catch up.

ChatGPT’s Response

ChatGPT begins with what to think about when selecting a mattress for a small canine:

First rate info for a small canine, however I’m right here for purchasing, and that is the place the response turns into fascinating:

You possibly can click on on the mattress, view pricing for a number of shops, however I didn’t purchase something to discover the characteristic any additional.

Gemini’s Response

Gemini’s response is one thing between ChatGPT and Claude. The beds they advocate are all actual and good choices, nevertheless it’s odd no hyperlinks have been offered. I’m assuming Google desires to “get their reduce” and can finally both provide paid advertisements for merchandise or obtain fee for these suggestions.

I do wish to point out that Google and PayPal have partnered to supply agentic commerce, which suggests they’re following within the footsteps of ChatGPT.

However, for this question, I used to be given a good response. So, what did I do? I requested Gemini why they gained’t present hyperlinks, and the response was fascinating:

Should you ask Gemini to supply hyperlinks, it tells you that it can’t. However in case you run info queries, it usually hyperlinks sources.

Let’s see what occurs with Claude.

Claude’s Response

Claude’s response was extra fundamental, which is to be anticipated:

Claude did its greatest, and whereas the response is nice in case you’re in search of several types of beds, it’s nonetheless fundamental. However keep in mind, this isn’t the platform’s power. For basic coding, I’ve discovered Claude to be higher than ChatGPT.

Gemini feels prefer it’s holding again with offering “clickable hyperlinks,” however I’m betting on this altering sooner or later.

Superior Immediate: I Need To Turn out to be An Authority In website positioning. What Steps Ought to I Take To Attain This Objective?

Up till this level, the prompts have been a bit straightforward. Let’s learn how every chatbot performs after we use extra superior prompts:

ChatGPT’s Response

ChatGPT’s new response is extra sturdy than prior to now. Curiously, each produced 9 factors that have been very comparable.

I do just like the suggestions for taking programs, gaining hands-on expertise, and even locations to learn information on website positioning.

Subsequent up, let’s check the identical question on Gemini.

Gemini’s Response

Gemini’s response is in depth, they usually present a stable record of suggestions. You’ll discover locations to visitor publish and instruments to make use of within the suggestions. I wish to see extra details about steady studying on the primary immediate, however there’s solely a lot that it’s going to present with out additional probing.

Claude’s Response

Claude has a variety of good recommendations, and I particularly just like the point out of various programs you’ll be able to take to study the fundamentals. Prior to now, once I ran this question, it talked about certifications, which it appears to have ditched this time round.

However Claude did have a couple of suggestions on complementary abilities to study, which is neat:

Total, the ideas from all three chatbots have been nice. Claude may use a bit assistance on the formatting finish. ChatGPT and Gemini each offered a wealth of suggestions that you may then dive extra into for a higher understanding.

Let’s strive placing these chatbots to work on some duties that I’m certain they’ll carry out.

Superior Immediate: Create A Robots.txt File The place I Block Google Search Bot, Disguise My “Personal” Folder, And Block The Following IP Deal with “123.123.123.123”

ChatGPT’s Response

ChatGPT listened to my instructions, reiterated them to me, confirmed me what to do, defined that I can’t block IP addresses in my robots.txt, after which defined find out how to block them in .htaccess. I’m impressed.

In comparison with previous years, the formatting has additionally improved, particularly with highlighting the code.

Gemini’s Response

Gemini did very well with this process, however there’s an issue. Should you have a look at the robots.txt, it does block Googlebot and provides me a snippet to unblock Bingbot, nevertheless it’s additionally blocking all crawlers on the high by default, which isn’t what I requested.

What would occur if I requested the identical factor, however blocked Bing as a substitute? Will it advocate the identical?

Let’s discover out:

Is Gemini favoring Google? I don’t know, nevertheless it’s odd that within the second instance, it blocked simply Bingbot and never each person agent.

Conspiracy? Coincidence?

I’m unsure, and I gained’t draw any conclusions with no a lot bigger dataset.

Claude’s Response

Claude does very well, with an identical rationalization on the robots.txt, which I’m completely happy all the chatbots caught as a result of it was an intentional immediate to see if they’d point out it or not.

Gemini will get the worst score on this one just because (and because of this it’s necessary to verify info) in case you copied and pasted the robots.txt, you’d block all person brokers.

Now, let’s strive a extra enjoyable, superior immediate.

Superior Immediate: What Are The High 3 Locations In Italy To Go to, And What Ought to I Know Earlier than Visiting Them?

ChatGPT’s Response

All three suggestions remained the identical through the years, however non-paid this 12 months is nearer to what ChatGPT Plus really useful the 12 months prior. Even the phrasing was comparable. I do assume that the formatting has improved, too.

As a follow-up query, I requested what sun shades to put on in Italy throughout my journey, and the response was:

In previous years, a few of these sun shades have been really useful, however with the addition of having the ability to view and even purchase them in ChatGPT, it makes the expertise so significantly better.

Gemini’s Response

Gemini did very well right here, and the identical format was given for:

Should you’re curious what Bard (sure, the unique model from Google) really useful years in the past, right here it’s:

Gemini is lightyears forward of Bard, and I actually like how they put all the things right into a desk to make it good and neat. I even acquired tips about:

• Finest instances to go to.
• Eating.
• Getting round.
• What to put on.

Once I requested about sun shades to put on, it got here up quick in comparison with ChatGPT as a result of it offers suggestions and proposals, however there are not any hyperlinks to particular sun shades to purchase. See for your self:

I used to be additionally informed about common manufacturers in Italy, however with out product hyperlinks, it falls quick.

Claude’s Response

All the info is stable, however I type of miss the format of final 12 months’s outcomes.

Claude’s response is spectacular. Rome, Florence, and Venice are all talked about.

Key sights are offered, with further suggestions for visiting, that are extraordinarily useful and correct.

Suggestions offered have been to:

• Study the language.
• Validate prepare tickets.
• Be ready for retailers and eating places to be closed within the afternoon.

And for the sun shades question, you be the choose. Among the suggestions on the record could also be out of vary for a lot of vacationers:

First rate suggestions with a follow-up query of the place I’m going in Italy. I did reply that query, and the platform informed me a bit concerning the area.

From the formatting to the response, I really feel like Claude has regressed this 12 months.

Why?

Have a look at final 12 months, the place precise sun shades have been really useful, and I had properly formatted responses:

Total, I’ve to go along with ChatGPT for this question due to its product hyperlinks. When it comes to info, Gemini was on par with ChatGPT, however Claude has regressed.

Which Chatbot Is Higher At This Stage?

Every instrument has its personal strengths and weaknesses.

It’s clear that Gemini has gotten lots higher and leveled the taking part in discipline. Gemini has a pleasant UI, and I imagine it has the potential so as to add hyperlinks to merchandise tomorrow if it wished to.

Claude’s bot could be very polished and perfect for individuals in search of in-depth solutions with explanations, however don’t anticipate hyperlinks again to sources for all the things, even when net search is enabled. I additionally really feel like the shortage of formatting is a matter (for me, at the very least).

ChatGPT is the higher possibility for purchasing in the intervening time, however every has its strengths:

• ChatGPT is greatest for on a regular basis solutions, merchandise, voice chat, and pc use.
• Gemini is greatest for deep analysis and video technology.
• Claude is greatest for writing and coding.

Hallucinations Can Occur

Chatbots can hallucinate, however they’re additionally very convincing of their responses. It’s necessary to heed the warning of the builders.

ChatGPT tells us:

Google tells us:

Claude additionally tells us:

Should you’re utilizing chatbots for something requiring information and research, cross-check your work and confirm that the information and occasions truly occurred.

There have been instances when these hallucinations are obvious and different instances when non-experts would simply be fooled by the response they obtain.

Since chatbots study from info, corresponding to web sites, they’re solely as correct as the knowledge they obtain – for now.

One research from February 2025 reveals that 91% of chatbot information responses present issues. Double-check responses, as Gemini and Claude advocate, as a result of bots get issues unsuitable.

You may as well discover circumstances the place:

• An Alabama lawyer was kicked off of a case as a result of ChatGPT made up pretend citations.
• A person was hospitalized due to asking ChatGPT about eradicating salt from his weight loss plan, main him to interchange sodium chloride with sodium bromide.

With all of those cautions in thoughts, let’s begin prompting every bot to see which supplies the perfect solutions.

Abstract

ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude are all fascinating instruments, however what does the long run maintain for publishers and customers? That’s one thing I can’t reply; nobody can but.

Preliminary outcomes present that even when there are “extra searches,” fewer individuals are getting referrals. Since July 2025, referrals from LLMs have been down by 42.6%, which is problematic for publishers and enterprise homeowners who have been hoping LLMs would direct site visitors again to their websites.

Extra Assets:

Featured Picture: Roman Samborskyi/Shutterstock